Press Release
Mutual Bancorp Reports on 2025 Performance and Strategic Progress at Annual Meeting of Corporators
Release Date: Spring 2026
Hyannis, MA – Mutual Bancorp recently shared an update on its financial performance and strategic progress at its Annual Meeting of the Corporators, highlighting continued balance sheet strength, core earnings momentum, and advancement of its multi-bank holding company model.
In 2025, Mutual Bancorp strengthened its financial position and delivered strong underlying results, increasing its tier1 leverage ratio by 63 basis points, reflecting proactive balance sheet deleveraging and continued capital growth. On a core basis, net income increased by nearly 70% year-over-year, driven by disciplined balance sheet management and prior restructuring actions. Fourth quarter net interest margin exceeded 3%, benefitting from diversified non-interest income streams and disciplined expense growth while continuing to invest in people and technology.
“These results reflect the strength of our core earnings profile and the value of our long-term strategy,” said Matt Burke, Chairman & CEO of Mutual Bancorp. “They are also a testament to the dedication and collaboration of our team, whose efforts continue to drive our success and deliver value to our customers and communities. Being recognized once again as a top workplace further reinforces the strength of our culture and the important role our employees play in advancing our mission.”
Cape Cod 5 Performance Highlights
Cape Cod 5 delivered strong performance across key business lines:
- Achieved approximately 26% deposit market share across its footprint
- Maintained #1 market share in residential lending and expanded FHA and VA offerings
- Ranked #3 mortgage lender in Massachusetts (The Banker & Tradesman)
- Grew commercial loans by 4.5% to nearly $1 billion
- Increased Wealth Management AUM by 8%
- Contributed over $1.8 million to local communities
The Bank also enhanced business online banking, upgraded mortgage systems, and continued investing in digital and client experience capabilities. The recently reopened Orleans Banking Center underscores its long-term commitment to the region.
Fidelity Bank Highlights
Fidelity Bank continued to build momentum in 2025, with a focus on enhancing client experience and strengthening its operating platform:
- Implemented upgraded Online and Mobile Banking platforms for consumer and business clients
- Introduced an enhanced mortgage point-of-sale and loan origination system
- Began rollout of contactless debit cards
- Advanced technology infrastructure, security, and operational capabilities
These investments reflect the progress made in leveraging Mutual Bancorp’s shared resources to support Fidelity Bank’s community-focused model, positioning it for continued growth and success.
Advancing the Mutual Bancorp Model
Mutual Bancorp’s shared services model remains central to its strategy, enabling investments in technology, data, and operations while driving efficiency and scale. This approach supports each bank’s local focus while enhancing capabilities across the organization, including digital channels, data insights, and process automation.
“The strength of our organization is grounded in the leadership across each of our banks and shared services teams,” Matt said. “We are fortunate to have experienced, forward-looking leaders guiding our efforts, including the recent appointment of Sean O’Connell as President of Fidelity Bank. Their collective focus on our mission and commitment to collaboration position us well to continue delivering value across our organization.”
The model continues to position Mutual Bancorp to navigate industry challenges, support its banks, and deliver long-term value to clients, colleagues, and communities.
Looking Ahead
Mutual Bancorp remains focused on continuously enhancing its capabilities to better serve clients and communities, with ongoing investments in people, technology, and data to support a more personalized, efficient, and secure banking experience.
The organization also highlighted the anticipated addition of Bluestone Bank to the Mutual Bancorp family. This expansion represents a natural next step in the evolution of the multi-bank model – bringing together institutions with shared values and a commitment to community banking, while further increasing scale, resources, and long-term sustainability. Upon completion, Bluestone Bank will further enhance Mutual Bancorp’s ability to invest, grow, and deliver value across its family of banks.
About Mutual Bancorp | About Cape Cod 5 | About Fidelity Bank